England v West Indies, 2nd Test, Edgbaston


ScorecardDay 1
Bulletin – Trescothick sets the pace for England
Verdict – Bravo keeps the discipline
Roving Reporter – Age concerns
Day 2
Bulletin – Windies fight back after Flintoff blitz
Verdict – Flintoff confirms his coming-of-ageDay 3
Bulletin – England build the foundations
Verdict – A new and triumphant England
Roving Reporter – Give us a clueDay 4
Bulletin – England retain the Wisden Trophy
Verdict – Giles rips out the cream of the Caribbean batting

McGrath and Gillespie strangle India

Scorecard and ball-by-ball details

20-12-18-2: Glenn McGrath’s figures in his 100th Test, an accurate and hostile reminder of what he can do at his best© Getty Images

Only in cricket can pigeon mean predator. Glenn McGrath, playing his 100th Test, spearheaded a powerful Australian attack, perhaps their best in the subcontinent, as India were restricted to 146 for 5 in reply to 398. They were choked for runs, and no-one pulled the noose tighter than McGrath, who took 2 for 18 in his 20 overs. Mohammad Kaif’s 47 not out, an innings that was both obdurate and fluent, helped India back on track, but Australia were far ahead.Start as you mean to go on, they say, but India’s start was completely at odds with what followed. Virender Sehwag smashed four boundaries off Jason Gillespie’s first over, but once he was out, the runs stopped flowing. Or even trickling. Aakash Chopra made 9 off 42 balls, Rahul Dravid made 21 off 140, and Sachin Tendulkar managed 8 off 36. The Indians collected only 60 runs in the afternoon session, as the run rate dived below two an over, and stayed there. It was not all the batsmen’s fault. The bowling was magnificent.McGrath’s bowling was an encapsulation of his essence. It was as if he strode in to bowl and said to the world, “You want to see how I’ve made it this far? Watch this.” His line was mostly in that narrow strip that is so often described as the corridor, which leads batsmen to their doom. His length, just back-of-a-length, allowed the batsmen neither to drive nor cut or pull. And he got the ball to jab both ways, teasing and tormenting. He only took two wickets all day, but what wickets they were – Sehwag, the irresistible force, and Dravid, the immovable object.His companions were lesser men only in comparison to him. Gillespie, after that first burst of looseners, bowled with hostility all day long, and Michael Kasprowicz was accurate and parsimonious, and unlucky not to take a wicket. They relished bowling on a pitch that offered them pace, even bounce and some lateral movement, and their strategy was to prise out wickets by restricting runs. Australia had decided that, while bowling, defence was the best form of attack, and they were vindicated.

Jason Gillespie: after being hammered in his first over, bowled with fire all day© AFP

It didn’t work for Dravid, though. His innings was a puzzling throwback to the early part of his career, when his immaculate defence was often not matched by the elegant strokeplay that makes him such a joy to watch. Sanjay Manjrekar once remarked that Dravid during India’s tour of Australia in 1999-2000 had made the same mistake that Manjrekar himself had made there in 1991-92: focussing on keeping his wicket intact and not caring to score runs. With that approach, you could spend two or three hours at the crease, but it would be to no avail when you got out, because the score would not have progressed much. In Dravid’s defence, though, it must be said that the bowling was outstanding, and quite a few crisp shots failed to elude the fielders, who were lively and athletic. A great foe can make a lesser man of anyone.Tendulkar played with self-restraint and obvious determination, but was set up beautifully by Gillespie, and was lbw for 8 to a lovely incutter (49 for 3). VVS Laxman came in and batted uncertainly against the fast bowlers, but it was again to Shane Warne that he perished, rocking back to a short one that spun away from him prodigiously, and trying to cut, only managing a top-edge to Michael Clarke at point (75 for 4). Dravid was out shortly after tea, lured into edging a staple McGrath delivery to slip (103 for 5).Kaif was the most impressive of the Indian batsmen on view. He played the kind of innings one has come to expect from Dravid, defending solidly but keeping the scoreboard ticking, and capitalising on loose balls. He survived an uncertain period against Gillespie just before close of play, when Gillespie kept bowling short to him. Kaif was well supported by Parthiv Patel, whose batting, at odds with his shambolic wicketkeeping, was adequate against all the challenges thrown his way. The last of them involved McGrath bowling with a close-in circle of seven fielders on the off side, like the broken seal of a bottle of mineral water. To his credit, he survived.It had been a good day for the bowlers from the start. The morning had begun with the threat of Clarke, aided by the tailenders, taking Australia much closer to 500, which would have shut India out of the match. But India struck with the second new ball, as Zaheer Khan bowled beautifully to pick up the wickets of Clarke and Gillespie. McGrath played an entertaining cameo of 11 not out, which included two hooks for four, and some immaculate head-over-the-ball elbow-high defence.But it was with the ball that McGrath would dominate. The Australian bowlers charged in, and the Indians crawled all day. Now would they die, or rise up?

'New throwing law will be easier to apply' – Mani

Ehsan Mani: ‘Once we put the criteria in place no-one can breach it’© Getty Images

Ehsan Mani, the president of the International Cricket Council, has said that the proposed throwing rules would be fairer as well as easier to apply. He added that the old limits were not foolproof as they had been set without any scientific evidence. This statement came in after a number of cricketers, both current and former, had raised severe objections to the change in the law, allowing all bowlers a 15 degree limit to flex their arms.”What we are trying to do is to come to a system which is fair,” Mani told Reuters. “Once we put the criteria in place no-one can breach it. Our cricket committee has recommended 15 degree tolerance-limit for all bowlers because bio-mechanics have told us that if the bowling arm is bent less than 15 degrees the human eye cannot detect it.”Mani also elaborated on the procedure that will be followed if a bowler’s action is found suspect. “What we are looking at, at the moment, is a two-stage process. If a bowler gets reported, his home board takes over the process. He has six weeks to correct his action during which he can play and once the home board feels he is OK, he can continue without worrying about his action.”The minute a bowler is reported, his action will be analysed in a laboratory and if the experiments show that he is going beyond the level of tolerance, the ICC will step in immediately and testing will be done under our supervision at 15 degrees. And it has to be done in four weeks.”The current set of rules allow varying degrees of flexing for different types of bowlers with fast bowlers, medium pacers and spinners having limits of 10, 7.5 and 5 degrees respectively. Regarding the new rule, Mani said, “In lab conditions if it is shown that straightening of the arm is more than 15 degrees, he [the bowler] will not be allowed to play.”Mani was asked about Muttiah Muralitharan, whose career has been dogged by allegations of throwing. “His action is so quick that the speed at which his arm comes down is quicker than most fast bowlers. We realised that some slow bowlers’ arm actions were as quick as those of fast bowlers. So the question arose whether to treat them as fast bowlers or spinners. Instead of getting involved in that sort of discussion, we thought it better to have same level for everyone.”Mani also revealed that the ICC now planned to send the proposal back to the bowling review sub-committee of the Marylebone Cricket Club and request the panel to give their feedback on the relevance of the law. The committee will be headed by Tony Lewis, the former England captain.

'We have to be patient' – Wright

Anil Kumble is one of the three spinners playing for India at Kanpur© Getty Images

The thinking behind three spinners
It was not an easy call but Sourav [Ganguly] felt that was best way to get the 20 wickets. We need to take wickets early tomorrow.On the what challenge is
We have to be patient. The wicket is bit slower and some of the boys mentioned that they can beat them in the flight but can’t make much use of the bounce.Why Irfan Pathan was left out
Irfan has been out for a bit through injury and Zaheer [Khan] has bowled pretty well this year. He [Zaheer] has got a bit more pace, he’s been reversing ball the well and was the pick of the two based in the ODI against Pakistan last week.The way South Africa played…
Their application stood out today – they showed a lot of determination. We’re going to have to work particularly hard on this pitch which is on the slower side.…and his own charges
I was pleased with the way we stuck at it throughout the day; would have been nice to get a wicket in the final session.

Sri Lankans thank New Zealand Cricket

Aravinda de Silva thanked New Zealand’s cricket board on behalf of Sri Lanka Cricket© Getty Images

Brendon Kuruppu, the Sri Lankan team manager, said he was deeply grateful to New Zealand Cricket and its officials for coming to their help at the hour of need.Aravinda de Silva, who is now vice-president of Sri Lanka Cricket (SLC), also thanked NZC for being considerate enough to understand Sri Lanka’s situation and agree to postpone the tour after just the first one-day international. He said that SLC had a commitment towards New Zealand to fulfil the abandoned tour within the next 18 months.Marvin Atapattu, the former Test captain, who had visited Galle and Matara, towns on the south of the island, when he returned from New Zealand said the disaster which had struck Sri Lanka was a big ordeal for any cricketer to handle individually. He said that his players would join SLC in a unilateral effort to ensure they achieve their ultimate goal of building houses for the needy.de Silva said SLC’s immediate task was to find shelter, clothing and food to those displaced, and to this end, it had opened up three camps at Dambulla, Matara and Galle, where SLC officials are already busy attending to the needs. He said that SLC would publicly announce its disaster action program on Wednesday.With no firm international commitments till June when the West Indies are due to visit for a full Test series, Atapattu indicated that the energies of his team would be diverted to relief work. He explained that it was a blessing in disguise that his team did not have any immediate international tours. Otherwise it would be difficult for the players to concentrate on the game while the rest of the country was suffering.Atapattu went on to say that it wouldn’t be a problem for any of his players to represent an Asian XI, if selected, against the ICC XI in a limited-overs match because it was being played to raise funds for the countries affected by the tsunamis. Sri Lanka, where more than 30,000 people are estimated to have been killed, is one of the worst hit of the seven countries affected by the giant tidal waves.Not all the national cricketers were present at yesterday’s media conference. Some had travelled to Trincomalee on Monday night to get a first hand view of the situation there.

Windward Islands fight back in low-scoring game

Windward Islands 63 (Kelly 6-31) and 69 for 4 (Fedee 30*) need 132 more runs to beat Trinidad & Tobago 160 and 104 (Shillingford 4-20)
ScorecardThe match between Trinidad and Tobago and Windward Islands at Arnos Vale was intrigingly poised after the second day, with Windward needing 133 more for victory with six wickets in hand. Trinidad had been in charge after the first day, but Windward fought back well on the second. Their last two wickets added 40 more in the morning to take their first-innings total to 63. Then, their bowlers bundled out Trinidad for a paltry 104 in the second innings, with Shane Shillingford taking 4 for 20. Sergio Fedee led the Windward run-chase with an unbeaten 30, but on a pitch heavily favouring the bowlers, Trinidad would still fancy their chances of a victory. Earlier, Richard Kelly starred with both bat and ball for Trinidad – he took 6 for 31 in Windward’s first innings, and then top-scored with 26, making exactly a quarter of his team’s total.Guyana 13 for 0 trail Jamaica 410 for 6 dec (Parchment 100, Baugh 100*, Bernard 84, Lambert 61) by 397 runs
ScorecardBrenton Parchment and Carlton Baugh slammed hundreds as Jamaica piled on the runs on the second day against Guyana at the Sabina Park in Kingston. Both batsmen scored exactly 100, with Baugh remaining unbeaten when Jamaica declared on 410 for 6. It was Parchment’s maiden first-class century and ended his poor trot which had kept him out of the side so far this season. David Bernard (84) and Tamar Lambert (61) chipped in with half-centuries as well, helping Jamaica amass a huge total. Narsingh Deonarine was Guyana’s most successful bowler, taking 4 for 75. Guyana then had three over to bat late in the evening, and they negotiated that little passage safely, scoring 13 without loss.
ScorecardA superb 126-run stand between Dale Richards and Pattrick Browne bailed Barbados out on the first day of their Carib Beer Cup match against Leeward Islands at Bridgetown. After winning the toss and choosing to bat, Barbados slumped to 87 for 5 before Richards and Browne got together. Both made half-centuries – Richards made 79 and Browne got 66 – as Barbados ended the day on 286 for 9. Adam Ssanford was Leeward’s most successful bowler, taking 5 for 92.

Pakistan agree to Ahmedabad one-dayer

Shaharyar Khan agrees to one extra one-dayer© AFP

The uncertainty over Pakistan’s tour to India has finally lifted with the Pakistan board agreeing to play an extra one-dayer at Ahmedabad, as proposed by the Indian board. Kolkata will now host a Test while Ahmedabad, where a Test was scheduled, will get the sixth one-dayer. However, the final schedule will be announced only after the Indian board resolved the TV rights issue, a delay that the PCB were willing to accomodate.In a press release issued today, the Pakistan board said that it understood the BCCI’s position with relation to postponement of the tour. “The PCB understands that the tour may have to be delayed by a few days in order to firm up administrative and logistical details.”The board also appointed Salim Altaf, who is the director of cricket operations of the PCB, as the manager of the team for the forthcoming tour of India. Asad Mustafa, who is currently PCB’s general manager of logistics, will be the assistant manager.It wasn’t yet revealed if this meant that Pakistan had also agreed to the BCCI’s decision to choose Kolkata as an alternate venue for the Test that had originally been allotted to Ahmedabad. Pakistan’s last Test there had been marred by crowd trouble, and their original request was for Mumbai. Chennai, with its famously sporting crowds, would also have been an acceptable choice to both teams.Meanwhile, the ICC has welcomed the resolution of the Ahmedabad issue. PTI reported Ehsan Mani, ICC’s president, as saying: “Everything was decided between the two boards. As it was a bilateral issue involving the boards of two countries, ICC could only play the role of a facilitator. Given the relations between Indian and Pakistan boards, I was confident of the issue being resolved amicably.”The issues over scheduling seem to be getting resolved, but the BCCI’s worries aren’t yet over. There’s still the TV rights to sort out.Also Read:Indian View – Can India match Pakistan’s grace and hospitality?

Mature Katich ready to replace Lehmann

Simon Katich performed strongly on last year’s tour to India, but they were his last Tests© Getty Images

Simon Katich, the favourite for the No. 6 Test spot, is confident he has developed the maturity to succeed at the highest level. Facing a friendly fight with Brad Hodge for the vacancy left by Darren Lehmann’s shoulder surgery, Katich was yesterday picked in the 13-man Test squad and felt ready to perform.The past 18 months have been difficult for Katich. He has looked on the verge of sealing a place only to be dropped and asked to force his way back. Andrew Symonds was preferred during the first two Tests in Sri Lanka in 2004 and Katich performed credibly batting at No. 3 in India when Ricky Ponting was injured, but was dumped for the series against New Zealand. After playing 13 Tests and 14 ODIs, including two as opener in the current series, Katich said he has adapted to the international game’s demands.”When I think back to 1999 I don’t think I was ready,” Katich told The Australian of his first Sri Lanka tour, where he suffered from chicken pox. “I don’t think I’ve really matured in terms of developing my game until the last couple of years.”Katich said even though he was 29 he was young in international terms, and was able to cope with the disappointment of missing out. “In the last 18 months I feel I’ve been really happy with the way I’ve progressed,” he told the Courier Mail. “I didn’t think that it would never happen again, but you also think ‘what happens if everyone plays really well for a year or two?'”The first Test starts at Christchurch on Thursday.

Malinga shines but Test drawn

Scorecard and ball-by-ball details
How they were out

Lasith Malinga sizzling spell gave Sri Lanka the vital breakthroughs on the fifth day© Getty Images

The first Test, which had apparently been heading towards an inevitable stalemate after the high first-innings totals on a docile Napier pitch, crackled into life on the final morning before fading out into a draw when bad light stopped play shortly after tea. Nevertheless, New Zealand, apparently safeafter scoring a mountainous 561, were given a real fright by Sri Lanka’s freakish new fast bowler, Lasith Malinga, who snapped up his first Test five-for and a virgin Man-of-the-Match award with a superb display.Malinga, who started New Zealand’s problems in the fading light on the fourth evening, striking twice before the close of play, sent tremors through the NewZealand dressing-room with his Waqar Younis-like reverse swinging toecrushers, askill learnt while playing softball cricket for hour after hour in the coconutgroves around Galle. The game turned around with remarkable speed as New Zealandcrumbled from 51 without loss to 148 for 7 at lunch. With a lead of just 211, the quick clatter of the remaining wickets could have paved the way for a Sri Lanka win.But Stephen Fleming’s late arrival at the crease stopped the New Zealand meltdown. He had earlier been forced to retire hurt after being able to grip the bat properly with his left hand, which was injured in the field, but clung on at the crease like a limpet, eating up precious time and overs during a 20.3 over partnership with Lou Vincent after lunch. New Zealand were eventually bowled out for 238 but that left Sri Lanka facing an impossible target of 302 from 27 overs.Vincent’s fine contribution to saving the game cannot be overestimated.Arriving at the crease with New Zealand in a mess on 85 for 4, he reacted to the intense pressure well and was not forced into his shell, an approach thatcould have been fatal. From his first shot, a neat paddle-sweep to leg, he actively searched out scoring opportunities, intelligently striking the right balance between attack and defence. His run scoring dried up slightly during the afternoon session but his 52 from 112 balls was an invaluable hand in the circumstances.Sri Lanka, though, felt aggrieved that Vincent stood his ground and was given anapparent let-off after driving a low catch to Tillakaratne Dilshan at short cover. Dilshan and the surrounding fielders were convinced the catch was taken cleanly – so convinced that there was not even an appeal – but Vincent, as is quite entitled to do, waited for clarification. With the umpires unsure the decision went upstairs to the television and, predictably, the pictures left an element of doubt as they so often do for bump catches.That was a crucial moment but Sri Lanka were also unlucky later in the session when Kyle Mills snicked one off Malinga and should have been given out by Steve Bucknor. It was Bucknor’s third clear mistake in the innings after Hamish Marshall’s caught-behind reprieve the previous evening which was followed by a dreadful lbw decision. Whether the decisions were crucial to the games outcome though is debatable – the first blunder was cancelled out by the second and the third came too late in the day.Sri Lanka eventually broke through in the second hour of the post-lunch session as Upul Chandana, who was called into the fray surprisingly late considering thefifth-day footmarks, sneaked through Vincent’s defences while bowling into the rough from around the wicket. But by that stage the door had already closed for Sri Lanka with the lead being 264 with too few overs and the only prize available was a fifth wicket for Malinga, which he deservedly took to finish with 9 for 210 from 59.4 overs.It was a riveting contribution. While other more orthodox bowlers were frustrated by the unhelpful pitch he was a constant threat. Revealingly, he bowled the most overs for Sri Lanka in both innings and yet never seemed to tire, constantly stretching his small frame like an elastic band in the hope of another spell. By contrast, Chaminda Vaas had a poor game match apart from his first spell on the first morning, bowling at a pedestrian pace and lacking his customary incisiveness on flat pitches.In the morning, Malinga followed up his two wickets in Thursday’s fading light with a first-over dismissal of the nightwatchman, Paul Wiseman, who missed a low full toss. A few moments later Malinga also bowled Nathan Astle (19) with a yorker but, for the second time in the match, the bails did not fall. Then, right at the end of the session after being called up for the final over, Malinga knocked back James Franklin’s off stump.In between, Sanath Jayasuriya played a crucial hand with his canny and mean left-arm spin. Keeping a lid on the scoring he built up pressure, stopping New Zealand from pulling away, and he also chimed in with a couple of vital wickets, including James Marshall who was trapped lbw after missing an arm ball, and Brendon McCullum.Astle’s good fortune to survive Malinga was followed in the second hour by awretchedly unlucky dismissal when Jayasuriya managed to deflect a straight-driveback onto the stumps at the non-striker’s end. Astle’s bat hovered just millimeters about the crease-line but the television umpire correctly ruled him out – a wicket that effectively put Sri Lanka in the driver’s seat. Fleming and Vincent though thwarted their victory bid.How they were out Missed a low full toss. Missed an arm ball that would have crashed into middle-and-leg. Run out at the non-striker’s end after Jayasuriya deflected a drive. Outside edge to slip as he tried to work to leg. Outside edge to slip as he tried to work to leg. Yorked himself while playing to leg out of the rough. Mistimed heave over the top, simple catch to mid-on. Top edged a pull into the deep.

Inzamam: 'The more you captain, the more you learn'

Inzamam has been advised to take three weeks’ rest after injuring his back© Getty Images

On the importance of Younis and Malik
Malik has been performing for a while and Younis had a good time in theTests. They are good boys. Now they are seniors and it is theirresponsibility to perform.On the team being weak
The team was not weak, but young.The pitch?
The pitch was slow and low.On what he has learnt as captain
[Jocularly] I get more angry. The more you captain, the more you learn.About his bad back
There’s a bit of a problem, and the physio has advised three weeks’ rest.About the extensive travel
[Again jokes] Travel-travel karke meri kamar chali gayi hai [I’vetravelled so much my back has given way].About the amount of cricket played
There is so much cricket around the world, you just have to get used toit. If there is big gap between matches, that can also harm.On Afridi’s innings
Afridi’s 40 was important. He lifted the pace, and India became defensive.

Game
Register
Service
Bonus